Failure: The Secret Confidence Builder

January 6, 2026

How intentional failure builds real confidence
By Dr. Brittany Herrick

We’re far enough into this “era” to understand that failure isn’t inherently negative. In many cases, it’s temporary—and when approached thoughtfully, it can be an opportunity to learn from what didn’t go well. I appreciate this shift. Reframing failure as information rather than a personal flaw is an important step forward.

What still feels missing from the conversation, however, is the intentional pursuit of failure—not recklessly, but deliberately. Growth doesn’t only come from learning after something goes wrong; it also comes from testing limits and discovering where our actual failure points are.

I’m not suggesting we seek failure with reckless abandon. Instead, we can systematically challenge ourselves in ways that are physically and psychologically safe, using failure as feedback. Often, when we do this, we realize we were capable of far more than we assumed—and that our perceived limits weren’t as close as we thought.

Many people avoid pushing boundaries altogether, whether physically, mentally, or emotionally. Avoidance can feel protective in the moment, but over time it limits growth. When challenge is consistently avoided, capacity doesn’t expand.

Physical Failure: Learning Through Effort

One place this shows up clearly—especially for women—is the gym. To be clear, most people should not regularly train to physical failure. That said, never approaching challenge out of fear of failure also comes at a cost. Learning where your current capacity ends—while still maintaining quality—is an important part of progress.

Trying a heavier lift than you’re confident with. Progressing a movement you’ve learned by increasing load, speed, duration, or time under tension—while maintaining technical standards. Reaching a point where you can no longer complete another repetition to that standard is not a setback. It’s valuable feedback. In this context, failure isn’t about breakdown—it’s about discovering the edge of your current capacity, which often builds confidence rather than erodes it.

Mental Failure: Testing Decision-Making and Adaptability

Mental failure often shows up when we intentionally place limits on certainty or control. Making decisions with incomplete information. Choosing action over over-analysis. Committing to a strategy without knowing whether it will work.

These moments are uncomfortable by design. They reveal how we respond to uncertainty, where we default to avoidance, and how much cognitive flexibility we actually have under pressure. Mental failure, in this context, isn’t about being wrong—it’s about discovering the limits of our current thinking and expanding our tolerance for ambiguity.

When approached intentionally, these challenges sharpen judgment, improve adaptability, and reduce fear around decision-making—key components of durable confidence.

Emotional Failure: Risking Discomfort and Vulnerability

Emotional failure is often the most avoided—and arguably the most important. This is where we risk discomfort, judgment, or rejection.

It shows up when we speak up in a meeting and our idea isn’t received. When we give honest feedback and it doesn’t land well. When we try a new behavior change strategy and fall back into old habits during a stressful week. Even planning well and still ending up grabbing food from a gas station or fast-food restaurant can feel like an emotional failure, especially for people working to change long-standing patterns.

These moments aren’t moral failures. They’re data points. They show us where systems break down under pressure and where additional support or structure may be needed.

This type of failure also extends beyond individuals. Leaders risk emotional failure when they initiate difficult conversations. Employees risk it when they ask questions or advocate for themselves. Parents risk it when they try a new approach. Teammates and colleagues risk it when they speak up. Often, the worst outcome is simply hearing “no”—but avoiding the attempt altogether guarantees stagnation.

Why Failure Drives Evolution

Interestingly, some industries actively seek failure. In technology and gaming, teams intentionally look for bugs. Systems are stress-tested not because perfection is expected, but because identifying weaknesses early allows for improvement.

Human development works the same way.

Failure isn’t the goal. Adaptation is. When we approach challenge intentionally—across physical, mental, and emotional domains—we expand what we’re capable of handling. Over time, this process builds resilience, confidence, and capacity.

That process—repeated, intentional, and safe—is what evolution actually looks like.

What are you waiting for? Join AMRAP today!

Schedule your free trial today to get started.

Book Your Free Trial